Networking in Berkshire - Business Event Details

Confidential Information and employment: dos and don’ts

In this article, Dr Maria Anassutzi, intellectual property expert, analyses and discusses the various issues employers must look for when trying to protect their intellectual property, know-how and confidential information from their employees and independent consultants.

The law regarding the confidentiality obligations that employees owe to their employer was reviewed in 1997. While an employer is entitled to restrain unauthorised disclosure or use of confidential information, employees are entitled, for public policy reasons, to use their acquired skill and knowledge for another employer. In fact, where the employer's right to restrain misuse of his confidential information collides with the public policy, it is the latter which prevails. The critical question is how to distinguish information which can be treated as an employee's acquired skill and knowledge from that which is not. The test for distinguishing such information is whether the information in question can fairly be regarded as a separate part of the employee's stock of knowledge which a man of ordinary honesty and intelligence would recognise to be the property of his old employer, and not his own to do as he likes with.

There are three specific categories of confidential information:

- Trivial: information that, due to its trivial character or its easy accessibility from public sources, cannot be regarded as confidential.

- Confidential: information that the employee must treat as confidential because: (i) the employee is expressly told it is confidential; or (ii) from its character it obviously is confidential. This information, once learned, necessarily remains in the employee's head and becomes part of the employee’s own skill and knowledge applied in the course of the employer's business. Generally, an existing employee can be stopped from misusing or disclosing this information but will not impose any implied restrictions on the employee’s ability to use or disclose it, even to a subsequent competing employer, after the employment ends.

- Trade secrets: information that, by its nature, is highly confidential and is referred to as "trade secrets" or their equivalent: for example, chemical formulae, designs or special methods of construction. The courts will imply terms to protect this against misuse or disclosure post-employment.

Trade secrets include information used in a trade or business which is subject to limited dissemination (or at least where widespread publication is not encouraged) but which, if disclosed to a competitor, would be liable to cause real (or significant) harm to the owner of the secret.

Therefore the implied duty can extend to cover highly confidential information that is not just of a technical or scientific nature. Information concerning personal relationships can also be trade secrets for the purposes of imposing implied restrictions post-employment. 

Sometimes, employers use restrictive covenants in the employment contracts to widen the implied protection. However, it is not clear from current cases to what extent non-disclosure non-use covenants can provide the former employer with any more protection than is already offered by the implied protection. "Confidential" (non-trade secret) information in certain instances was found to be protected by reasonable express post-employment covenants whereas in others it was not. Given this uncertainty, prudent employers should use these covenants carefully and always in proportion having regard to the level and seniority of the employee.

 

It is better not to identify the confidential subject matter that is being protected in the employment contract, since the employer may be able to find alternative arguments for justifying the restrictive covenant if challenged. The subject matter may include objective knowledge constituting the employer's trade secrets. However, it cannot include the skill, experience, know-how and general knowledge acquired by an employee as part of the job during employment.


There are three specific categories of confidential information:

- Trivial: information that, due to its trivial character or its easy accessibility from public sources, cannot be regarded as confidential.

- Confidential: information that the employee must treat as confidential because: (i) the employee is expressly told it is confidential; or (ii) from its character it obviously is confidential. This information, once learned, necessarily remains in the employee's head and becomes part of the employee’s own skill and knowledge applied in the course of the employer's business. Generally, an existing employee can be stopped from misusing or disclosing this information but will not impose any implied restrictions on the employee’s ability to use or disclose it, even to a subsequent competing employer, after the employment ends.

- Trade secrets: information that, by its nature, is highly confidential and is referred to as "trade secrets" or their equivalent: for example, chemical formulae, designs or special methods of construction. The courts will imply terms to protect this against misuse or disclosure post-employment.

Trade secrets include information used in a trade or business which is subject to limited dissemination (or at least where widespread publication is not encouraged) but which, if disclosed to a competitor, would be liable to cause real (or significant) harm to the owner of the secret.

Therefore the implied duty can extend to cover highly confidential information that is not just of a technical or scientific nature. Information concerning personal relationships can also be trade secrets for the purposes of imposing implied restrictions post-employment.

 

Sometimes, employers use restrictive covenants in the employment contracts to widen the implied protection. However, it is not clear from current cases to what extent non-disclosure non-use covenants can provide the former employer with any more protection than is already offered by the implied protection. "Confidential" (non-trade secret) information in certain instances was found to be protected by reasonable express post-employment covenants whereas in others it was not. Given this uncertainty, prudent employers should use these covenants carefully and always in proportion having regard to the level and seniority of the employee.

 

It is better not to identify the confidential subject matter that is being protected in the employment contract, since the employer may be able to find alternative arguments for justifying the restrictive covenant if challenged. The subject matter may include objective knowledge constituting the employer's trade secrets. However, it cannot include the skill, experience, know-how and general knowledge acquired by an employee as part of the job during employment.

Another way employers can protect their know-how and confidential information is to include a provision in the employment contract for a specified period of "garden leave". During this time the employee remains employed but does not attend work. As a result, the employee is effectively denied access to the company's information and contractually bound not to work for anyone else. The implied protections do not survive during this period so a garden leave clause should include express terms to continue the implied obligations of confidentiality, at least until the period ends.

These clauses are particularly beneficial to protect information that is commercially sensitive whilst current but not a trade secret (that is, which may not be protectable post-employment, even with an express provision). However, a long period of garden leave may have an adverse impact on the enforceability of otherwise reasonable restrictive covenants, in particular if the latter also last for a long period. Therefore, it is not uncommon to provide for a corresponding reduction in the restraint period for each day of garden leave served.

                                            

Employers seeking court protection need to take action promptly to restrain any misuse of IP rights or confidential information. Delay is a bar to injunctive relief, particularly where the employer has allowed the employee to set up or join a competing venture before deciding to take action. For example, a delay of two months may be considered unreasonable.

 

It is also essential that the employer is not in material breach of the employment contract. Where this is the case, the former employee can rescind the contract and all its clauses, including the restrictive covenants. This is the case even where the covenant is stated to apply after the termination of the contract "howsoever arising". For example, attempts by the employer to make a non-contractual payment in lieu of notice could trigger a wrongful dismissal claim and leave the contract unenforceable. Therefore, where the enforcement of post-termination covenants is important, it is important to include a payment in lieu of notice provision.

 

However all cases are considered on a case by case basis, where an independent contractor was involved it was held that a provision protecting confidential information continued to apply after the termination of a contract for services despite a repudiatory breach of the agreement. Significantly, the court held that it would have come to the same conclusion if the case had involved an employee, arguing that there could be no justification for making a wrongly dismissed employee "a present" of his employer's trade secrets or other confidences.

 

All articles are for general purposes and guidance only and do not constitute legal or professional advice.

Copyright 2010 Anassutzi & Co Limited. All rights reserved. Information may be shared or reproduced only if accompanied by the author’s name and bio.

For more information email maria@anassutzi.com

Views: 7

Add a Comment

You need to be a member of Networking in Berkshire - Business Event Details to add comments!

Join Networking in Berkshire - Business Event Details

Featured Companies

Action Coach Business Coaching, (View events)

Take your business to the next level!


Web Design & Online
Marketing

Let our team boost your sales by enhancing your online presence! Request a free consultation.


Claritas Accountancy

Helping you to grow your business to its full potential. 


Peninsula - HR & Health & Safety Services

Support to help advise, protect and grow organisations.


Get 'Featured' here

Business Directory

Find local companies, member profiles & get listed:

Directory

Latest Member Activity

Jennifer Pennington posted a blog post
Thursday
Jennifer Pennington is now a member of Networking in Berkshire - Business Event Details
Thursday
Clear House Accountants is now a member of Networking in Berkshire - Business Event Details
Nov 7
Rob Pickering posted a blog post
Nov 6

Follow us

© 2018   Created by Chris Lunn.   Powered by

Member e-Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service